Saturday, February 21, 2009

The Rockologist: Sympathy For The Opening Band

One of the things I really enjoy doing with these Rockologist columns is recalling some of my favorite memories from decades of attending rock concerts. I've been going to concerts since I was about twelve years old, and by my most conservative estimate I've probably seen thousands of them.

My very first was a Jefferson Airplane concert back in the sixties in Hawaii that my mom only allowed me to attend if I was accompanied by my grandma (true story). To her credit, "Nana" was a very good sport about the whole thing -- even if I doubt very much she understood any of it.

As the hippies smoked their pot, and the psychedelic lights swirled behind Grace and Marty, my Grandma -- who was actually pretty hip as Grandmas go -- sat politely in her seat making sure none of the joints being passed around came anywhere near her then twelve year old charge.

But what I remember most about that night was the guy who played first.

He was a keyboard player named Lee Michaels who performed on a Hammond organ, backed only by a bank of Marshall amps and this drummer named Frosty. It was really loud, it didn't make a lot of sense, and it was also really great. Michaels, who would have a hit a few years later with the song "Do Ya' Know What I Mean," was the first of my many memorable experiences of being surprised by the opening act at a concert.

For many concert-goers, the opening act is an afterthought at best. It's what the rest of the crowd is doing while you're across the street getting a pre-concert buzz at the nearest bar, or who is finishing up as you're showing up at the last minute to find your seat. Conversely, there is also a certain breed of concert snob who will tell you they are only there to see the opening band, as in "Screw U2, I'm just here to see PJ Harvey."

Sound familiar?

Some bands don't use opening acts at all. Every time I've seen Led Zeppelin or Bruce Springsteen for example, it's always been billed as "an evening with" the headliner. Although I know for a fact that Bruce once opened for Chicago early in his career. Hell, Jimi Hendrix's first American tour was as the support act for the Monkees.

My point here is, if you've been going to rock shows as long as I have, sometimes an opening act will surprise you.

I can remember for example seeing Jethro Tull on their tour for Aqualung, where the opening band was a band then still largely unheard of called Yes. This was one of the rare occasions I can ever recall where the openers were not only called back for an encore, but where Tull's people eventually had to run out and pathetically ask the crowd if "anybody here has ever heard of Jethro Tull?"

Yes were really that good, and as God is my witness, I didn't just make that up either.

I also once attended a show by the great Van Morrison, where Nick Lowe and Dave Edmunds' shit-hot at the time band Rockpile were the openers. More than half of the crowd in attendance were new wave hipsters who came just to see them. When Rockpile were through with their thirty minute set, so was the trendy portion of the crowd who came just to see them. Van looked confused when he hit the stage to a half empty house, and showed his disgust by performing with his back to the crowd for most of the show. It was their loss.

The fact is, of all the great bands I've seen over the years, many of them were bands I first witnessed as opening acts. The short list of these would include Yes, Kiss, Rush, Robin Trower, Blue Oyster Cult, Bob Seger, Tower Of Power, Uriah Heep, Black Oak Arkansas, Bad Company, the Eagles, Cheap Trick, Love And Rockets, Tom Petty, Kings Of Leon, and AC/DC.

Yes AC/DC. The first time I saw them, they were the openers for Ted Nugent and nobody had any idea who they were. By the end of their set, with Angus hauling Bon Scott through the arena on his shoulders, the crowd was sold though. It was the beginning of a long love affair with Seattle for the Aussie bad boys.

On the other side of the coin, I've also witnessed more than my fair share of shows where the opening band was heckled -- or far worse. Some of these instances were simply cases of really ill conceived booking on the part of the concert promoters.

I can recall for example, a J. Geils Band concert which was opened by a guy named Rick Roberts (who would later go on to a brief, but decent career with the band Firefall). Roberts had the unenviable task of serenading the boogie hungry J. Geils crowd with nothing else but his voice and an acoustic guitar. The crowd was merciless. I actually bumped into Roberts in the mens room during the intermission, and found myself doing my best to console the poor guy, who was in tears.

The same thing happened a few years later when Graham Parker opened for Thin Lizzy. Parker was greeted by shouts of "punk-rock fag" from the crowd. You have to understand that this was at a time when rock music had become very polarized along genre lines. I ended up buying Parker a drink later that night at the hotel bar, and telling him I thought he sounded great.

Every once in a while though, the openers will fight back.

Around the same time as the Parker/Lizzy incident, I saw a band called Rubicon open for who I want to say was either Elvis Costello or Patti Smith, and get mercilessly booed by the crowd. Rather than give up however, the Rubicon boys rose to the challenge and threw it right back at them. The lead singer hurled obscenities into the microphone, before being eventually unplugged and escorted off the stage by security.

One of the more audacious examples I can remember where an opener fought back was when a pre-Licensed To Ill Beastie Boys opened for Madonna's first tour in Seattle at the Paramount Theatre. The Beasties came out and proclaimed themselves to be the "kings of the Paramount" as though they were the headliners, and were promptly booed out of the building.

I had the unenviable task of interviewing them later that night, and they remained unapologetic -- swilling beer and slamming their fists down next to my tape recorder during the interview (which I was never able to transcribe as a result).

I've also seen cases where the opening act was so openly dissed by the promoters it was almost laughable. I'll never forget one of the first big stadium rock shows I attended back in the seventies where a band called Starz opened for Aerosmith and Jeff Beck. As we walked into the stadium an hour before the scheduled start, there were the poor guys in Starz playing with all the house lights up in the 70,000 seat Kingdome.

You simply couldn't help but feel sorry for them.

I guess my point in all of this would simply be this.

As important as I know the whole experience of pre-concert chow and drinks can be, and in fact is -- you might want to consider being in your seat in time to catch the opening band.

In addition to knowing the gratitude of your fellow concert-goers for not blocking their view as you search for your seat right when Bruce or whoever is about to go on, you might just catch something to remember.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Thin Lizzy Are Still Dangerous After All These Years

Music Review: Thin Lizzy - Still Dangerous: Live at the Tower Theater Philadelphia 1977

Jailbreak (and to a lesser extent, Johnny The Fox) notwithstanding, even Thin Lizzy's most ardent fans would probably admit that the seventies Irish hard rock band was spotty at best when it came to their studio albums.

Not so as a live band however. Onstage Thin Lizzy was another story -- some would say they were another band -- entirely. With the classic lineup of vocalist/bassist Phil Lynott, drummer Brian Downey, and the dual lead guitar attack of Scott Gorham and Brian Robertson, Lizzy's high energy shows in fact earned them a reputation as one of the best live bands of their era. If there was a such thing as a don't miss act outside of Zeppelin and the Who way back then, Thin Lizzy was it -- or at least, they were about as close as you could get.

For that reason, Thin Lizzy's Live & Dangerous remains one of the seminal live hard rock albums of the seventies. Unfortunately, it's never had a sequel -- at least, until now.

With the new Still Dangerous: Live at the Tower Theater Philadelphia 1977, the newly christened VH1 Classics label, along with the folks at Eagle Rock, have unearthed a gem of a long lost Thin Lizzy show.

Culled from tapes recently discovered by guitarist Scott Gorham, the CD captures Thin Lizzy playing their asses off at a Philadelphia show, that is remixed and remastered here by legendary Rolling Stones producer Glyn Johns -- who came out of retirement to do the honors. The only question here is, how on earth could a show this smoking hot have sat in a box gathering dust all these years?

What you hear on this CD is the sound of a still hungry band just coming off a successful tour that most observers felt was about to propel them to that next level of superstardom. They sound like it too. On the album's ten tracks, Lizzy sound like a much tighter band than they ever did on Live & Dangerous. Yet they match the energy of that classic show riff for riff. The dual leads of Gorham and Robertson -- which predated the southern-rock model of bands like the Allmans and Skynyrd by a few years -- cut particularly sharp here, proving just how underrated they really were.

For his part, Lynott keeps things mean and lean as well, particularly on the nicely segued triplet of "Jailbreak," "Cowboy Song," and "The Boys Are Back In Town." Eschewing his occasional tendency for verbiage of the sort worthy of Springsteen, Lynott is strictly business here. The band rips through these songs with the sort of energy that almost leads you to believe they had a plane to catch or something (and I mean that as a compliment).

Where Live & Dangerous might represent a full course meal in the grand scheme of a great live document, Still Dangerous: Live at the Tower Theater Philadelphia 1977 plays more like the sort of tasty appetizer that leaves you hungry for more. For those already aware of Lizzy's credentials as a great band, this CD will be a nice surprise. For those newer to the band, this is a great place to start.

Friday, February 13, 2009

A Mixed Bag of "Alt-Rock" From The Basement

Music DVD Review: -
From The Basement

What we have here is a DVD that comes exactly as advertised. Which is to say that it delivers on its promise of a series of live performances recorded in the studio, without any big production values -- hence the "from the basement" title and theme. The performances seen and heard here were also done mostly without any audience. I say "mostly" only because light applause can occasionally be heard.

As for the artists represented here, they fall mostly under the banner of what might be called "alternative" -- whatever that means these days, since what is heard here is stylistically pretty much all over the place. But there are some big "alt-rock" names here, including Beck, PJ Harvey, the White Stripes, and Sonic Youth.

The biggest of these names is of course Radiohead, who also get the lions share of the playing time here with four tracks represented. Two of these ("Down Is The New Up" and "Videotape") close the DVD, and are credited to lead vocalist Thom Yorke, who does perform them solo. But let's face it, they are still Radiohead tracks.

The full band opens the DVD with "All I Need" and "Reckoner," two tracks from the great In Rainbows album. I had already seen Radiohead's stuff when it was shown on VH1 last year, but it's still nice to have here to play whenever the mood strikes. You can never have enough of Radiohead doing stuff from In Rainbows.

But Radiohead are not the only highlight here. The two White Stripes tracks serve as a reminder of just how great Jack White is on guitar (and how Meg pounds the shit out of those drums). The Beck stuff is, well, Beck. PJ Harvey hits some unearthly high notes behind a metronome and an acoustic piano on "The Devil." Sonic Youth sound great walking a tightrope between post-punk and psychedelia on "The Sprawl" and "Pink Steam."

As for the rest of what's here? Well, I have to be honest here and say I skipped through some of it. I'm sure Neil Hannon and Laura Marling are fine songwriters for example, but I lasted less than a minute with each of them. Something about those acoustic guitars and dour faces I guess. Hey, I had a deadline, okay?

On the other hand, there were also some quite pleasant surprises on From The Basement. I definitely liked the doomy lo-fi minor chords of Autolux for example, even if their song "Let It be Broken" sounded suspiciously like a slowed-down version of "Pinball Wizard." I also dug the fuzzed-out rock of Albert Hammond Jr. and the sleepy dirge-rock of Super Furry Animals. And I was already a fan of the Shins. Ditto the Eels.

So my short review reads like this. If you're a Radiohead completist, you want this. Just consider the White Stripes, Sonic Youth, and PJ a nice little bonus. But if you're not, there's plenty of other great stuff here you might also like or otherwise be surprised by as much as I was. There's also some filler. But that's what the skip button is for.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Handicapping The Grammys: My 2009 Predictions

Fasten your seatbelts kids. It's Grammy time.

Whether you love the Grammys or hate them, one thing's for sure. You can't beat the entertainment they've got lined up this year. Were talking McCartney, U2, Coldplay, and Radiohead for starters. So even if the choices of the historically stodgy academy makes you want to throw things at your TV, at least you know you're going to get some quality music.

But the Grammys don't exactly have a very good track record when it comes to making forward looking choices. Eventually they'll usually get it right, handing out awards to the people who deserve them, but it's usually years after the fact. Just ask Dylan or the Rolling Stones.

Frustratingly, the Academy will more often get it wrong though, and sometimes wildly so. Past honorees for best new artist for example include such one-hit wonders as the Starland Vocal Band (remember "Afternoon Delight"?), and the most famous lip-synching band of all time, Milli Vanilli. The first year that Grammy decided to honor heavy metal in a category, the recording academy chose to honor those mosh-pit favorites Jethro Tull over Metallica.

Still, the beat goes on at the Grammys. What follows is my own predictions for how I expect things to go down tonight. I base these on gut more than anything else, and the list should by no means considered in any way scientific, or something you want to bet the house and the kids on.

Record Of The Year

Chasing Pavements Adele
Viva La Vida Coldplay
Bleeding Love Leona Lewis
Paper Planes M.I.A
Please Read The Letter Robert Plant & Alison Krauss
SHOULD WIN: Coldplay
WILL WIN: Coldplay

It should be a big night for Coldplay.

Album Of The Year

Viva La Vida Coldplay
Tha Carter III Lil Wayne
Year Of The Gentleman Ne-Yo (LOL)
Raising Sand - Robert Plant & Alison Krauss
In Rainbows Radiohead
SHOULD WIN: Radiohead
WILL WIN: Plant/Krauss

Radiohead's album set a new standard for music distribution that turned the record industry on it's ear, but Plant and Krauss is a safer choice because Coldplay and Radiohead are going to split the rock vote, and Radiohead is just a bit too experimental for take home one of the big three. Besides, Grammy loves all that O' Brother Where Art Thou kind of shit, right? I'd call Coldplay a dark horse here, but I also wouldn't be betting on that Led Zeppelin reunion tour happening anytime soon after tonight.

Song Of The Year

American Boy - William Adams, Keith Harris, Josh Lopez, Caleb Speir, John Stephens, Estelle Swaray & Kanye West, songwriters
Chasing Pavements - Adele Adkins, songwriter
I’m Yours - Jason Mraz, songwriter
Love Song - Sara Bareilles, songwriter
Viva La Vida - Guy Berryman, Jonny Buckland, Will Champion & Chris Martin, songwriters

SHOULD WIN: Coldplay
WILL WIN: Coldplay

Splits on Record and Song of the Year are very rare.

Best New Artist

Adele
Duffy
Jonas Brothers (LOL)
Lady Antebellum
Jazmine Sullivan

SHOULD WIN: Duffy
WILL WIN: Jonas Brothers

Duffy's album was by far the most interesting of all of the nominees here, but the Jo-Bros have the most name familiarity.

Best Female Pop Vocal Performance

Chasing Pavements - Adele
Love Song - Sara Bareilles
Mercy - Duffy
Bleeding Love - Leona Lewis
I Kissed A Girl - Katy Perry
So What - P!nk

SHOULD WIN: Duffy
WILL WIN: Pink

This is a tough one this year. Katy Perry's song was by far the biggest of the lot, but I just don't see Grammy honoring a song about lesbianism. My gut tells me Grammy goes with the familiar here, which is why I'm going with Pink.

Best Rock Performance By A Duo Or Group With Vocals

Rock And Roll Train - AC/DC
Violet Hill - Coldplay
Long Road Out Of Eden - The Eagles
Sex On Fire - Kings of Leon
House of Cards - Radiohead

SHOULD WIN: Kings Of Leon
WILL WIN: Coldplay

Kings of Leon had a huge breakthrough this year, but if the Grammys do what they usually do, it'll be a few more years before they catch up to them. The Eagles are a dark horse here for pretty much the same reason, but once again I think this is gonna' be a big night for Coldplay.


Best Rock Album

Viva La Vida - Coldplay
Rock n Roll Jesus - Kid Rock
Only By The Night - Kings of Leon
Death Magnetic - Metallica
Consolers of the Lonely - The Raconteurs

SHOULD WIN: Coldplay
WILL WIN: Coldplay

The Raconteurs are my personal favorites in this category. Kid Rock's "All Summer Long" was arguably the song of the summer. But once again, I'm really smelling that Coldplay sweep.

Best Alternative Album

In Rainbows - Radiohead
Evil Urges - My Morning Jacket
Modern Guilt - Beck
Narrow Stairs - Death Cab For Cutie
The Odd Couple - Gnarls Barkley

SHOULD WIN: Radiohead
WILL WIN: Radiohead

As the only album here also nominated for album of the year, Radiohead is a shoo-in. Although, a win for My Morning Jacket would also be a nice surprise.

Best R&B Vocal Performance by a Female

Me Myself and I - Beyonce
Heaven Sent - Keyshia Cole
Spotlight - JHud
Superwoman - Alicia Keys
Need U Bad - Jazmine Sullivan

SHOULD WIN: Alicia Keys
WILL WIN: Alicia Keys

The Grammys love Alicia Keys.

Best Contemporary R&B Album:

Growing Pains - Mary J. Blige
Back of my lac - J Holiday
First Love - Karina
Year Of The Gentleman - Ne-Yo
Fearless -Jazmine Sullivan

SHOULD WIN: Mary J. Blige
WILL WIN:: Mary J. Blige

I was really tempted to say Ne-Yo wins this one. But my gut tells me it's Mary J.

Best Rap Album:

American Gangster - Jay Z
Tha Carter III - Lil Wayne
The Cool - Lupe Fiasco
Nas - Nas
Paper Trail - T.I.

SHOULD WIN: Nas
WILL WIN: Lil' Wayne

Nas' album was the most artistically bold, but Lil' Wayne had the biggest seller of 2008 period. Lil' Wayne will sweep the rap categories.

Best Solo Rock Vocal Performance

Gravity - John Mayer
I Saw Her Standing There - Paul McCartney
Girls In Their Summer Clothes - Bruce Springsteen
Rise - Eddie Vedder
No Hidden Path - Neil Young

SHOULD WIN: Bruce Springsteen
WILL WIN: Bruce Springsteen

I'm not sure why a song from a 2007 release is even here, but Bruce's song is by far the most recognizable here (well, outside of the nearly fifty year old Beatles song anyway). The fact that Macca is actually performing at the show makes him a dark horse, and Neil Young is certainly overdue. But I say Springsteen takes this.

Best Rock Song

Girls In Their Summer Clothes - Bruce Springsteen
House Of Cards - Radiohead
I Will Possess Your Heart - Death Cab For Cutie
Sex On Fire - Kings Of Leon
Violet Hill - Coldplay

SHOULD WIN: Bruce Springsteen
WILL WIN: Coldplay

Even the Boss won't be able to stop Coldplay's momentum tonight.

Saturday, February 7, 2009

The Rockologist: New Vs Old Adventures In Ticket-Buying

Unless you were away somewhere on a desert island or a on distant planet -- or of course, you simply don't follow these things -- then you are probably aware that Bruce Springsteen released a new album, played the Super Bowl, and announced yet another tour with the E Street Band this week.

Speaking of which, is there anyone besides me out there who remembers when Springsteen tours with the E Street Band used to be rare and special events? These days, the guy trots out the boys for another worldwide juggernaut nearly as often as Dylan does. Oh, right -- his tours used to be pretty rare too.

Not that I'm complaining or anything...

So, as we Springsteen fans tend to be a somewhat fussy lot, it goes without saying that not everyone was going to be happy with those damned capitalists at TicketBastard this week.

Personally, I'm just pissed that Bruce apparently isn't getting anywhere near the Northwest part of the country this time around. He probably still holds it against us that we didn't sell out the Tacoma Dome back in the Nineties on the Human Touch/Lucky Town tour -- to which I say, get over it, Bruce, okay? Nobody else sold that one out either.

But back to TicketBastard. When big-time tours like Bruce, U2, and the like go on sale, everybody pretty much knows that these guys are a necessary evil. As such, fans have come to expect the usual outrageous service fees, system overloads, and computer glitches. It's just part of the deal we have all come to expect.

We either don't get the tickets, or we get shitty seats -- even though we had fifteen windows open at 10 AM. When by 10:01, the only seats left in the house are the nosebleeds, we also suspect the usual hanky-panky with scalpers and ticket-brokers. We then complain about it, and in the case of Springsteen, go to BTX for a decent ticket, then forget about it, and start making plans for the big show.

At least, that's how it usually works. Not so this time.

When Springsteen tickets went on sale this past Monday, TicketBastard did all of the usual things it can always be counted on to do. The system froze, credit cards and accounts weren't recognized, and those damn security code-words couldn't be read without industrial-grade bifocals. But then, there was a most interesting new wrinkle...

On the east coast, in particular, ticket buyers got redirected from TicketBastard to the even nastier bastards at TicketsNow. For those unaware, TicketsNow is essentially one of those ticket broker sites that can get you premium seats -- for those willing to pay prices up to triple or more of their face value. TicketBastard apparently has some sort of business arrangement with these fine folks.

Super Bowl and Obama inaugural triumphs aside, Springsteen himself hasn't had a great month anyway. The new album has gotten mixed reviews, and he recently apologized to fans for selling a new greatest hits package exclusively at the decidedly labor-unfriendly retailer WalMart.

This week, Springsteen and his management had to apologize again for the TicketsNow debacle, which is something that, as a fan, I give him all due credit for doing.

In fact, this in turn prompted a counter-apology from TicketBastard CEO Irving Azoff, in which he went so far as to offer those fans who got stiffed by the TicketsNow re-direct to make up the difference on the inflated prices they ended up paying.

Anyway, all of this got me to thinking back about how different purchasing tickets used to be back in the old days.

In Seattle, this usually meant going down to the Fidelity Lane ticket office, looking at a seating chart, and haggling over what seat you preferred with the nice ticket lady at the counter. Choice meant standing in lines that were long at times, often behind a family buying tickets to the Ringling Brothers Circus or the Ice Capades. In a lot of ways, it was a real pain in the ass. But it worked.

Most importantly here, you still had choice. In other words, no computer generated "best available" bullshit, which at 10:02 on game-day can mean seats somewhere between the roof of the venue and just due south of Max's drum-riser behind the stage for an act like Springsteen. Which is exactly what I had to look at when I tried to get tickets for the nearest Springsteen show to my house -- some 900 miles away in San Jose, California.

Hardcore fan that I am, I reluctantly passed.

Speaking of Springsteen, I can also remember spending the night in many a ticket line for every Bruce tour between The River and Tunnel Of Love. The way the drill went here was that you showed up the night before at the ticket office with the essentials of sleeping bag, beer, and Bruce tapes (this was in the pre-CD era). And then you stayed up all night getting drunk and listening to Springsteen with your fellow Bruce fans.

You didn't sleep, and right around 2 or 3 AM you also started to freeze your ass off. But you also had a great time, and if you arrived early enough, you were guaranteed something in the first ten rows. Once you got your precious cargo, you then ran to the back of the line, flashing your tickets and joyously screaming something like "Tenth row, baby! Read em' and weep!" It was just too damn sweet, and worth every single freezing fucking cold, drunk on my twenty-something-years-old ass minute of it.

The ritual was similar for the other mega-tours. I have a distinct memory, for example, of spending the night in a local park in Seattle as a thirteen-year old with my buddy Dave Dudley. We stayed up all night, smoked an ungodly amount of weed, and then walked ten miles down to the Seattle Center to buy six-dollar tickets to see the Stones on the Exile On Main Street tour.

That's just the way that tickets were bought back then. And for six bucks! Can you imagine that now?

Like most other things these days that have come about as a result of our ever-increasing reliance on doing most everything by computer, I guess it comes down to a matter of convenience over a more personal experience.

I'd be kidding myself if I thought I could still do the sort of all-nighter in a ticket line that I did so many times in my reckless youth now. Hell, I don't even like standing on the floor at concerts these days.

Still, there was something to be said for looking at a seating chart, and taking however many minutes were necessary to choose the best one available.

I guess it all comes down to choice.

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Bonnaroo: Its Not Just For Hippies Anymore

Music DVD Review: - Live From Bonnaroo 2008

Although Tennessee's Bonnaroo started out as the ultimate modern-day "hippie festival" -- it was once even even brutally, but hilariously skewered as such by those evil kids on TV's South Park -- it has in recent years become much more than a showcase for jam bands like Phish and My Morning Jacket.

Over the years, Bonnaroo has in fact hosted everyone from Radiohead to Tom Petty to Willie Nelson to Metallica on its way to becoming what is arguably now the biggest of all the big summer music festivals. Rumor has it that none other than Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band will headline this year's Bonnaroo.

2008's lineup at Bonnaroo was as diverse as any in the festival's venerable history. In addition to the bands you'd more or less expect -- I mean what's Bonnaroo without My Morning Jacket, right? -- Bonnaroo 2008 featured everything from punk (Against Me!) to funky R&B (Sharon Jones & The Dap Kings) to metal (Metallica, Mastodon) to the God-knows-what-genre-it-is of Gogol Bordello. It seems these days that Bonnaroo is striving to be Lollapalooza as much as it is Woodstock.

All of this is captured on Live From Bonnaroo 2008, which condenses the entire Bonnaroo experience into roughly 100 minutes worth on DVD. Interspersed between performances by sixteen bands, are plenty of crowd shots from the festival, which gives this DVD the rock-doc feel of something like Woodstock or Monterey Pop.

There are interviews with both the diehards who come from all over the country to attend each year, as well as the so-called "Bonna-rookies." The film provides a pretty good overview of all the action, from the big boys on the mainstage, to the makeshift rave in a tent, to the comedy stage (where a stand-up comic compares his act to Metallica's). Both the video and 5.1 audio mix (taken direct from the soundboard) are stellar throughout.

As for the performances themselves? The standouts would include My Morning Jacket's Jim James going into his trademark trance-like state during "I'm Amazed," Pearl Jam's Eddie Vedder leading the crowd in a "fucking beautiful" (his words, not mine) sing-along during "Better Man," and the Raconteurs Jack White making an acoustic guitar sound as wicked as an electric during "Old Enough."

But, as it should be with any great festival, there are also plenty of new discoveries -- and surprises! -- here.

Like when the Lee Boys channel the spirit of Sly Stone doing "Higher" at Woodstock during their own "Come On, Help Me, Lift Him Up" in one of the most frenetic and energized takes on gospel music I think I've ever heard.

Sharon Jones & The Dap Kings are equally electrifying doing a high energy hybrid of funk, jazz and R&B on "Let Them Knock." Other standout performances on the DVD include Against Me!, Les Claypool, and Broken Social Scene. There is no shortage of great music on this DVD.

Strangely, Metallica's appearance here represents a low point. Although they appear to have the crowd eating out of their hand, I was a little surprised at how much energy they actually seemed to lack during "Fade To Black" here. Maybe it's just me, but they sounded kind of tired of here, and James Hetfield in particular also looked it. I'd definitely have to give Mastodon the decision in the Bonnaroo metal-matchup here.

For those of you with HD and surround-sound though, I cannot urge you strongly enough to crank this sucker up when you sit down to watch it -- especially during the sets by Sharon Jones and the Lee Boys. Thanks to this DVD, those are two artists I will definitely be investigating further.